Experienced trial lawyers With The Resources To Handle Your Case
The national trial lawyers
Best law firms us news 2017
Super lawyers
Million dollar advocates forum
Multi million dollar advocates forum
AV preeminent martindale-hubbell lawyer ratings
Litigator awards

NHTSA accountability–where should it start? Part 2

The Toyota unintended acceleration issue has demonstrated, determining why systems fail in complex mechanical and software related interactions is no easy matter. NASA was brought in to assist NHTSA on that matter, and they concluded there was no defect in the electronic throttle control system.

Toyota attempted to disarm allegations of many of these accidents as being essentially user error, suggesting that that driver stepped on the wrong foot peddle as they panicked. 

Nonetheless, when a California State Trooper, his wife, 13-year-old daughter and brother-in-law were killed when their Lexus vehicle crashed after accelerating to speeds of more than 120 miles per hour, Toyota was faced with a worst-case scenario.

It was more difficult for Toyota to asset that a state trooper was unaccustomed to the operation of a motor vehicle and that he would have been easily confused or panicked by the acceleration of the vehicle.

The defense in that case was also disadvantaged by the frightening 911 recording of the brother-in-law calling during the final seconds before the fatal crash. After the crash, another driver who had received the vehicle from the dealership as a loaner experienced a similar, out-of-control acceleration by same the vehicle.

The sheriff’s report on the accident suggested it was caused by an improperly sized floor mat placed in the vehicle by the dealership. The catastrophic damage was so great that it was impossible for investigators to examine the other electronic or mechanical systems for potential defects.

While NASA could not find any reproducible software errors and some vehicles seem to have suffered from “simple” problems, like incorrectly sized floor mats, the lack of certainty in the cause of these unintended acceleration accidents remains troubling.

In our next post, we consider what should be done to reduce the likelihood of these incidents.

FindLaw Network

$5.5 Million

Settlement for spinal injury caused by delivery company's negligent vehicle maintenance

$5 Million

Settlement for traumatic brain injury

$1.7 Million

Recovery for premise liability spinal cord injury, in which liability was disputed.

$1.55 Million

Workers’ compensation recovery for a partial leg amputation and traumatic brain injury, in which liability was disputed.

$1.2 Million

Settlement (Liability insurance limits) for death claim arising out of tractor trailer collision

$1 Million

Settlement for closed head injury/facial fractures due to negligent construction site practices

$1 Million

Arbitration award in death claim arising out of motor vehicle collision

$1 Million

Total workers' compensation settlement for injured worker who suffered orthopedic injuries and additional GI injuries due to prescription medications.


Settlement for head injury of injured worker caused by negligent operation of equipment by a non-employer contractor on the job site.


Settlement for ankle injury due to negligent dump truck operation


Recovery for a premise liability wrongful death and survival action, in which liability was disputed.


Workers’ compensation and personal injury recovery for foot injury and toe amputations.


Settlement for bilateral wrist injuries caused by the negligent operation of a tractor-trailer.


Workers’ compensation recovery for a fatal claim, in which liability was disputed.


Settlement for statutory cap of $500,000 for wrongful death of a worker who was killed when struck by a government-owned vehicle as well as policy limit for underinsured motorist coverage.


what our clients say about us

“I would like to sincerely thank you for your efforts in resolving my personal injury case. The consistent professionalism you and your firm provided demonstrated exactly how law is suppose to be handled. You helped to change my life and I will forever be in your debt.” - Satisfied Client
“It was not an easy road for us but we knew that we had a great attorney that cared about his clients. You are a fantastic attorney.”
“Just wanted to thank you again, so very much, for the TLC given us during our unfortunate situation; so greatly appreciated the ease and smoothness of handling things – you had so much to do!”
view more