Inner Banner Images

Experienced

TRIAL LAWYERS WITH THE RESOURCES TO HANDLE YOUR CASE

How effective are distracted driving laws?

Everyone knows that distracted driving is a serious problem. The news is nothing new. Even as far back as 2014, the National Safety Council said that roughly 5% of all crashes involved texting. They said another 21% of crashes involved people talking on their phones. We’ve known about the problem for years, but people keep using their phones while they’re on the road.

Pennsylvania has enforced a statewide texting ban since 2012 but still allows drivers to hold their cellphones to make calls. So just how effective is this texting ban? And how might things look if Pennsylvania adopted a handheld ban?

Texting Bans Save Lives

In 2014, The Washington Post reported on a study of the nation’s texting bans. The authors explored 11 years of data from 48 states and found that texting bans led to an 11% reduction of teen fatalities. But that wasn’t the only notable finding. The study also found that:

These findings suggest that Pennsylvania’s texting ban is a good first step, but that there’s good reason for lawmakers to explore a more restrictive handheld ban. ‘

Why Are Handheld Bans More Effective?

The Center for Injury Research and Policy at Nationwide Children’s Hospital led a study that looked at how teens responded to the different state-level texting and handheld laws. Unsurprisingly, it found that teens used their cellphones in staggering numbers, but the introduction of different laws led to some more surprising results.

One of the study’s authors said the results were evidence that more states should adopt handheld bans. The study didn’t offer concrete reasons for the greater impact of handheld laws over texting bans, but the authors felt it was likely due to the ease of enforcement. People believe it’s easier for an officer to recognize a phone held to the ear than to notice a driver typing on a phone in his or her lap.

The Biggest Part Of The Problem Remains

These studies argue that Pennsylvania’s texting ban is saving lives. They also suggest the law would be more effective if it just banned all handheld devices.

Even though laws can help, both studies suggest that laws aren’t enough on their own. Some people want to supplement the laws with widespread education and change programs. For now, the fact is that we still have a long way to go.